map vote sugestion

[Ritt]

i was thinking...
you know those end of map votes, when there are just no good maps so you just vote for some bad map you really don't want to play.

well i was thinking. what if every map vote there was a option for a random map. this would choose any map on the server. this would allow for the chance to play a map you like, as well as getting more maps played. i feel we play a total of like 5 maps on the server and it gets old. i like the idea of a random choice....

[Terran]

I think that it should ALWAYS go to a random map.

Each map should have a 100% chance to be picked. Since they're all 100%, that means one of them will be randomly picked. After being picked, that map will have a 99% chance. All the rest will be 100%, so it'll decide between them. Then the next one will be 99%. This'll happen until they're ALL 99%, where one will become 98% and it'll continue.

It'll guarantee a 100% FAIR and RANDOM cycle.

When one is 0%, it'll be removed temporarily. When the last map goes from 1% to 0%, it'll reset all to 100%.

At least, I think it'd work.

[Ritt]

(06-14-2015, 05:48 PM)Terran Wrote:  I think that it should ALWAYS go to a random map.

Each map should have a 100% chance to be picked. Since they're all 100%, that means one of them will be randomly picked. After being picked, that map will have a 99% chance. All the rest will be 100%, so it'll decide between them. Then the next one will be 99%. This'll happen until they're ALL 99%, where one will become 98% and it'll continue.

It'll guarantee a 100% FAIR and RANDOM cycle.

im not 100% sure what you mean by this. i could be reading it wrong but it just wont work in my head xd

[Dreadark]

pls do random maps.

[Terran]

Let's do 5 maps as an example. This is round 1.

Round 1:
Map 1: 100%
Map 2: 100%
Map 3: 100%
Map 4: 100%
Map 5: 100%
Map 3 is randomly picked. (Each map has a 100% chance, aka even. So its random.)

Round 2:
Map 1: 100%
Map 2: 100%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 100%
Map 5: 100%
As you see, Map 3 can't be picked because it is not 100%. So, one of maps 1, 2, 4 or 5 are picked. Let's skip ahead a few rounds.

Round 6:
Map 1: 99%
Map 2: 99%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 99%
Map 5: 99%
The last map to be chosen was Map 5 last round, which had the only 100% chance. Now all of the maps have a 99% chance. One of the maps is randomly picked. Map 4 is chosen.

Round 7
Map 1: 99%
Map 2: 99%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 98%
Map 5: 99%
Now, it will repeat!

[Dreadark]

It would probably take a year for all maps to get to 0%.

[Ritt]

(06-14-2015, 06:17 PM)Terran Wrote:  Let's do 5 maps as an example. This is round 1.

Round 1:
Map 1: 100%
Map 2: 100%
Map 3: 100%
Map 4: 100%
Map 5: 100%
Map 3 is randomly picked. (Each map has a 100% chance, aka even. So its random.)

Round 2:
Map 1: 100%
Map 2: 100%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 100%
Map 5: 100%
As you see, Map 3 can't be picked because it is not 100%. So, one of maps 1, 2, 4 or 5 are picked. Let's skip ahead a few rounds.

Round 6:
Map 1: 99%
Map 2: 99%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 99%
Map 5: 99%
The last map to be chosen was Map 5 last round, which had the only 100% chance. Now all of the maps have a 99% chance. One of the maps is randomly picked. Map 4 is chosen.

Round 7
Map 1: 99%
Map 2: 99%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 98%
Map 5: 99%
Now, it will repeat!

ok i get this, but i don't agree. it should just be random RGN no changing percentage. and the ability to choose maps should not be lost

[Soulmashed]

(06-14-2015, 06:33 PM)Derp-A-Doodle-Doo Wrote:  

(06-14-2015, 06:17 PM)Terran Wrote:  Let's do 5 maps as an example. This is round 1.

Round 1:
Map 1: 100%
Map 2: 100%
Map 3: 100%
Map 4: 100%
Map 5: 100%
Map 3 is randomly picked. (Each map has a 100% chance, aka even. So its random.)

Round 2:
Map 1: 100%
Map 2: 100%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 100%
Map 5: 100%
As you see, Map 3 can't be picked because it is not 100%. So, one of maps 1, 2, 4 or 5 are picked. Let's skip ahead a few rounds.

Round 6:
Map 1: 99%
Map 2: 99%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 99%
Map 5: 99%
The last map to be chosen was Map 5 last round, which had the only 100% chance. Now all of the maps have a 99% chance. One of the maps is randomly picked. Map 4 is chosen.

Round 7
Map 1: 99%
Map 2: 99%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 98%
Map 5: 99%
Now, it will repeat!

ok i get this, but i don't agree. it should just be random RGN no changing percentage. and the ability to choose maps should not be lost

But this way tjere would still be some unplayed maps that are in rotation the way terran said it means that EVERY map would be played at least once

[Ritt]

(06-14-2015, 06:46 PM)Soulmasher The Anti-Hallowed Wrote:  

(06-14-2015, 06:33 PM)Derp-A-Doodle-Doo Wrote:  

(06-14-2015, 06:17 PM)Terran Wrote:  Let's do 5 maps as an example. This is round 1.

Round 1:
Map 1: 100%
Map 2: 100%
Map 3: 100%
Map 4: 100%
Map 5: 100%
Map 3 is randomly picked. (Each map has a 100% chance, aka even. So its random.)

Round 2:
Map 1: 100%
Map 2: 100%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 100%
Map 5: 100%
As you see, Map 3 can't be picked because it is not 100%. So, one of maps 1, 2, 4 or 5 are picked. Let's skip ahead a few rounds.

Round 6:
Map 1: 99%
Map 2: 99%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 99%
Map 5: 99%
The last map to be chosen was Map 5 last round, which had the only 100% chance. Now all of the maps have a 99% chance. One of the maps is randomly picked. Map 4 is chosen.

Round 7
Map 1: 99%
Map 2: 99%
Map 3: 99%
Map 4: 98%
Map 5: 99%
Now, it will repeat!

ok i get this, but i don't agree. it should just be random RGN no changing percentage. and the ability to choose maps should not be lost

But this way tjere would still be some unplayed maps that are in rotation the way terran said it means that EVERY map would be played at least once

i guess that's true.

[Brassx]

I don't like this idea.

Let me point out some flaws:

Quote:you know those end of map votes, when there are just no good maps so you just vote for some bad map you really don't want to play.

well i was thinking. what if every map vote there was a option for a random map. this would choose any map on the server

You're complaining about playing a map you really don't want to play? But the random map option has a chance to get another bad map you don't want to play, thus completely nullifying the reasoning behind your suggestion in general..

100% random maps wouldn't be a good thing IMO, as I strongly believe players should have at least SOME control over what maps they play.