1. Do you still think this process is a good idea?
I'm not quite sure what you mean by process. I think the process to submit the ideas could be improved, but the concept of the crate is excellent. People submit item ideas they want to see in the server, and that definitely can improve the quality of it. I'd like to see more creative suggestions, rather than just new stat sets.
2. Would you like to see a continuation of this series? (as in community crate 2, etc)
Definitely.
3. Do you have any suggestions on how the submission/upvote process could be better?
The process could be something like this (I only put like a week's worth of thought into this, so it can probably be improved): Have a submission period for common ideas, and when that period is over, have a voting period for the common posts. During that voting time, it would also be the time to submit the uncommon ideas. This would continue until all the ideas are voted on and secured. I think more accepted ideas would be nice, rather than just 24 (I think that's how many were accepted), maybe have double that? There were more than 2 godlikes that I would have liked to see accepted, but only 2 were. Maybe have 3-4 godlikes, with a lower chance of dropping any of them? I just feel like a hell of a lot more thought went into the primordial and godlike suggestions than the lower tiers, and that a lot of that thought was wasted because of how many were accepted compared to how many were posted.
4. Are you pleased with the way the CC1 turned out?
For the most part, with the exception of the reasons I gave above.
Extra: If another high tier was added, somewhere in between legendary and primordial, still rare, but not 1 in 2000 chance to get them, I think it would help with where to put some submissions. A few times when I Was going to suggest something, I didn't know where to put it because it seemed a bit strong to be a legendary, but not quite unique enough to be a prim. ~ Food for thought.
I'm not quite sure what you mean by process. I think the process to submit the ideas could be improved, but the concept of the crate is excellent. People submit item ideas they want to see in the server, and that definitely can improve the quality of it. I'd like to see more creative suggestions, rather than just new stat sets.
2. Would you like to see a continuation of this series? (as in community crate 2, etc)
Definitely.
3. Do you have any suggestions on how the submission/upvote process could be better?
The process could be something like this (I only put like a week's worth of thought into this, so it can probably be improved): Have a submission period for common ideas, and when that period is over, have a voting period for the common posts. During that voting time, it would also be the time to submit the uncommon ideas. This would continue until all the ideas are voted on and secured. I think more accepted ideas would be nice, rather than just 24 (I think that's how many were accepted), maybe have double that? There were more than 2 godlikes that I would have liked to see accepted, but only 2 were. Maybe have 3-4 godlikes, with a lower chance of dropping any of them? I just feel like a hell of a lot more thought went into the primordial and godlike suggestions than the lower tiers, and that a lot of that thought was wasted because of how many were accepted compared to how many were posted.
4. Are you pleased with the way the CC1 turned out?
For the most part, with the exception of the reasons I gave above.
Extra: If another high tier was added, somewhere in between legendary and primordial, still rare, but not 1 in 2000 chance to get them, I think it would help with where to put some submissions. A few times when I Was going to suggest something, I didn't know where to put it because it seemed a bit strong to be a legendary, but not quite unique enough to be a prim. ~ Food for thought.